Popular Shelter Island Hotels

• Hotel Sunset Beach

  Guest rating: N/A

  Price from 261 €

  This beachfront boutique hotel boasts the Sunset Beach Restaurant and Bar and rooms with a flat-screen LCD TV. It is just 2 miles from the ferry to More...

Accommodation near Shelter Island

Due to limited offer of accommodation in Shelter Island we have extended accommodation possibilities by more offers in the nearest destinations of Shelter Island like Bridgehampton, Wainscott, East Hampton, Tuckahoe, Southampton. All accommodation (hotels, apartments, B&B) are sorted by geographical distance from Shelter Island. The distance could be adjusted by using the tool “Search in nearby destination”.

• Motel Enclave Inn Bridgehampton

  Guest rating: N/A

  Price from 57 €

  Distance: 16.0 km

  City: Bridgehampton,

  Located 3 miles from the Atlantic Ocean and 5 miles from East Hampton Main Beach, Enclave Inn Bridgehampton features an outdoor pool. Guest rooms offer patios More...

• Motel Enclave Inn Wainscott

  Guest rating: N/A

  Price from 57 €

  Distance: 16.8 km

  City: Wainscott,

  Located in the Hamptons in Wainscott, New York, this hotel is 4 miles from East Hampton Beach. It features an outdoor pool, private wooded grounds and rooms More...

• Hotel East Hampton House Resort

  Guest rating:
  83%

  Price from 86 €

  Distance: 19.1 km

  City: East Hampton,

  Situated on 5 acres of landscaped grounds, this hotel is within a 5-minute walk or less from the high-end shops and restaurants of East Hampton Village. It More...

• Hotel c/o The Maidstone

  Guest rating: N/A

  Price from 193 €

  Distance: 19.3 km

  City: East Hampton,

  Featuring a decorative collection of contemporary rooms and an on-site gourmet restaurant, this hotel overlooks the historic district of East Hampton. Each More...

• Motel Enclave Inn Southampton

  Guest rating: N/A

  Price from 57 €

  Distance: 20.2 km

  City: Tuckahoe,

  Located on the east side of Long Island, this motel is 10 minutes from Cooper's Beach in Southampton, New York. It features an outdoor pool and free in-room More...

• Hotel Southampton Inn

  Guest rating:
  83%

  Price from 135 €

  Distance: 21.2 km

  City: Southampton,

  Set on more than 5 acres of beautifully landscaped lawns, this Long Island hotel features a modern American restaurant with poolside service. Free summer More...

• Hotel The Bentley Hotel Southampton

  Guest rating:
  53%

  Price from 97 €

  Distance: 21.2 km

  City: Southampton,

  This Southampton, New York hotel is just 2.4 miles from Meschutt Beach County Park. It features outdoor tennis courts, a daily continental breakfast and bright More...

• Hotel The Atlantic

  Guest rating:
  66%

  Price from 75 €

  Distance: 21.2 km

  City: Shinnecock Hills,

  Located on Route 27, this Southampton hotel is 2.7 miles from Tiana Beach. It provides guests with complementary passes for 10 different area beaches and More...

• Hotel The Hampton Hamlet Inn

  Guest rating:
  79%

  Price from 75 €

  Distance: 22.0 km

  City: Southampton,

  Just steps from Shinnecock Bay, this Southampton hotel is 2 miles from Cooper’s Beach. It features spacious rooms with free Wi-Fi and serves a daily More...

• Hotel Saybrook Point Inn and Spa

  Guest rating:
  92%

  Price from 188 €

  Distance: 23.3 km

  City: Old Saybrook,

  This 4-star hotel is located in historic Old Saybrook along the Connecticut River. The hotel features indoor and outdoor saltwater pools, a full service spa More...

• Motel Ocean View Terrace

  Guest rating:
  78%

  Price from 83 €

  Distance: 23.8 km

  City: Hampton Bays,

  This motel overlooks Shinnecock Bay and is 3 miles from the Southampton Golf Club. The motel has a playground and a seasonal outdoor pool, rooms include free More...

• Days Inn Old Saybrook

  Guest rating:
  66%

  Price from 60 €

  Distance: 23.9 km

  City: Old Saybrook,

  This hotel is ideally situated off Interstate 95 in the city of Old Saybrook, Connecticut and only a short distance from many area attractions. Enjoy modern More...

• Hotel Econo Lodge Inn and Suites Old Saybrook

  Guest rating:
  72%

  Price from 60 €

  Distance: 24.0 km

  City: Old Saybrook,

  This Old Saybrook, Connecticut hotel is a 5-minute drive from Harvey’s Beach and the Katharine Hepburn Cultural Arts Center. It features a breakfast buffet and More...